The Canadian Dollar Faces Severe Strain

Advertisements

January 8, 2025

The Canadian dollar has been languishing at its lowest point since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, exacerbated by a mix of political instability and looming threats from tariffsIn response to these challenges, the Canadian government has announced a significant investment to bolster border security—allocating 1.3 billion Canadian dollars (approximately 900 million U.Sdollars) over the next six years to enhance measures at the nation's borders.

This decision comes in the wake of the United States imposing a 25% tariff on imports from North American trading partners, contingent on these countries taking steps to curb immigrationConsequently, Canadian officials are rolling out a budgetary plan aimed at fortifying border protections to ease concerns surrounding the potential impacts of these tariffs on the Canadian economy.

During a recent announcement, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's government outlined how the additional funding would be allocated

Officials indicated that the investment would be used for procuring police dogs, drones, helicopters, mobile surveillance towers, and bringing hundreds of new border personnel into the fold.

The Canadian government currently spends around 2.2 billion Canadian dollars annually on border enforcement and managementWith the economic repercussions of possible tariffs looming large, avoiding additional duties has become a pivotal concern for Canadian policymakersLeading economists predict that if the promised 25% tariffs are implemented, the Canadian economy could slide into recessionTiff Macklem, Governor of the Bank of Canada, noted that these tariffs are contributing to a climate of significant economic uncertainty.

Such an environment complicates decision-making for businesses; as Macklem observed earlier this month, firms may, in fact, scale back investments as a result of the heightened uncertainties

Nonetheless, the precise timeline for utilizing the allocated funds remains ambiguousOfficials suggest they may need to rent helicopters to expedite additional operations and reassign personnel from other departments to border patrol units.

On the diplomatic front, Dominic LeBlanc, a senior cabinet member, expressed optimism after conversations with Howard Lutnick and Tom Homan, a candidate to oversee border affairsHe asserted that cooperation with U.Spartners is ongoing and underpinned by a commitment to addressing their concerns about border integrity.

Trudeau took to social media to emphasize that the new funding delineates Canada’s dedication to maintaining a strong and secure borderHe pointed out that these efforts would also play a role in combatting issues like fentanyl production and money launderingHowever, the Prime Minister currently finds himself navigating a political crisis following the unexpected resignation of his closest ally, Chrystia Freeland, who departed due to unsettling shifts in fiscal policy direction.

Freeland openly expressed her concerns through a letter to Trudeau, criticizing the government’s heavy reliance on fiscal stimulus without adequately prioritizing the attraction of capital and investments to combat economic nationalism

In response to Freeland's departure, some members of the Liberal Party have started publicly calling for Trudeau to step down—a signal of possible internal dissentNeither Trudeau nor his office has commented on Freeland's exit.

Criticism of the border security plan has surfaced from various cornersBloc Québécois MP Alain Therrien described the spending initiative as inadequate, commenting that it appears too spread out over the remaining years of this decadeIn French, he stated, “It’s flimsy,” expressing skepticism about whether Canadians would feel reassured under such a plan.

Provincial leaders in Canada are also alarmed at the ramifications tariffs may have on the economy in their regionsThey have called for more robust measures at border enforcement, recognizing that a concerted approach is essential in the current climate.

On a more global scale, the Canadian dollar has taken a considerable hit in light of the ongoing political turmoil

alefox

Skylar Montgomery Koning, a currency strategist at Barclays, noted that the recent chaos in politics highlights broader issues affecting the currency, namely its weaker performance compared to the U.Sin combination with the looming tariff threatsHe projected continued downward pressure on the Canadian dollar moving forward.

Michael Puempel, a strategist at Deutsche Bank, suggested that recent political turbulence increases the likelihood of tariffs being enacted against CanadaHe conveyed to clients that unless there is a stabilization in Canadian political leadership, it is probable that extreme measures will continue to be taken concerning trade issues with one of America’s key trading partners.

Citing the potential outcomes, he indicated a fundamental shift toward more austere fiscal policies might be on the horizonMeanwhile, Jim Caron, Chief Investment Officer at Morgan Stanley Investment Management, emphasized that the Canadian economy is in a precarious position, worsening with the existing political strife

He highlighted that this dilemma not only stems from the interest rate disparity between Canada and the U.Sbut also from the political instability exerting additional pressure on the currency.

Brad Bechtel, Global Head of Foreign Exchange at Jefferies, anticipates that driven by seasonal liquidity factors, the Canadian dollar could even depreciate further against the U.Sdollar—potentially reaching a level of 1.4668. Such a rate was last observed in March 2020. With the Canadian dollar already showing an over 7% decline against the U.Sdollar this year, 2023 stands in line to register as the worst year since 2018. Recent data from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) indicates that hedge funds have ramped up short positions against the Canadian dollar in response to the market volatility.

In a report issued on Tuesday, Kit Juckes, Head of Currency Strategy at Société Générale, poignantly described the Canadian dollar as “enduring a thousand cuts of devaluation.” He pointed to the cancelation of rate support by the Bank of Canada, increased uncertainty regarding tariffs, and the government’s struggles with internal cohesion as core factors contributing to the currency’s instability.